Sports drinks or water?

 

What do you drink on game day?

Are sports drinks better than water?

There has been an explosion in recent times of sports drinks aimed at helping you perform ‘just that bit’ better. There are a number of products on the market, and more recently we’ve seen the introduction of sports water, to provide even more choice (read confusion) for active people.

The sports drinks category came about largely from research into improving elite athlete performance through hydration. Millions has been spent trying to tune sports drinks to elite athlete requirements. But do they help the average sports player?

According to the AIS, research shows that ‘fluid intake improves when fluids are cool, flavoured and contain sodium’.  Sports drinks have been designed based on this research.  By providing flavour, you’re more likely to keep drinking during activity, ensuring you get the fluid you need.  Sodium helps be increasing your fluid absorption and retention. Sports drinks also contain carbohydrates that supply the muscles with fuel during activity.

So where does this leave water? Water is still a necessary for anyone taking part in sports activity. It should be part of your pre activity hydration plan. However water alone may not stimulate fluid intake to the same extent as sports drinks. A study conducted with AIS netball and basketball players showed that players demonstrated a better fluid intake when drinking sports drinks. Recent evidence has also shown that the carbohydrate content of sports drinks has been beneficial for high intensity activity of 60 minutes or more.

So the evidence seems clear – you need water, but sports drinks can make a real difference in your performance.  What's your opinion?

COMMENTS
Sam
4:54pm, Tue 2 February
I've always been ok with drinking just water during sport until i started bikram yoga. Since then i do notice a difference during a 90 minute session, which i may not even make it through without at least electrolytes. I also need more salt in my diet now too. So sports drinks definitely help me.

On the topic of electrolytes though, i hear that the best source is not sports drinks, but coconut water, which you get from young coconuts (along with plenty of potassium and minerals). Apparently they give 3 times the electrolytes of most sports drinks, in a natural form. If you know where or how to get them however, please let me know as i cant find them for the life of me!

Graeme
10:03am, Sat 27 February
I used to be a fan of gatorade, but having found out that they are putting chemicals like brominated vegetable oils in some flavours (just to make it look better), I've gone back to good old water. There are many sites out there which point out the dangers of these chemicals and even though it is actually legal to use them, it doesn't make them any better for your long term health.
Here is just one link of many
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/823337/the_dangers_of_the_additive_brominated.html?cat=51

Chris
12:52pm, Sat 27 February
Sam, i hear that the Chinese water drinks are high in coconut water,get them at the local asisan grocery store.

Also on the topic of this research,most of the research is done by the companies private scientists and Institute of sport may have found these claims but i for one know that poweraide and such give you the energy well after the game is over,they do help but cordial is just as good..

Correy
5:24pm, Fri 19 March
I personally think that sports drink give you that extra 5

Nick
3:36pm, Wed 14 April
I personally use water but in that i mix a couple of pinches of celtic sea salt and a teaspoon of brown suger. Heard about this at a first aid course. Helps me nicely. Seams to me this is on the money and ticks all the boxes from the above article.

yoa
10:14pm, Fri 28 May
noun of Gatorade and staff in out Water is better for me i use it much more better and it helps better

J.Corning
6:26pm, Sun 6 June
I always have Gatorade after and before love making it realy works

R. Atkins
4:26pm, Mon 23 August
The science behind sports drink is very misleading and yes it is done by the companies themselves who should not be trusted. America's obese kids is due to sports drinks.
Sports drinks are made from acidic tap water with dangerous and toxic artificial sweeteners, preservatives and other chemicals that don't have to be mentioned as they are not an ingredients.
The human body is ONLY designed to work on Natural Mineral Water, that does not mean Spring water, as Australian bottled Spring water are all acidic, are very low in minerals and most are mixed with tap water.
When you are exercising, your body build lactic acid. The only thing that your body needs is pure water with mineral, like calcium, magnesium and sodium bicarbonate to help buffer the acidity from your body.
You can squeeze a little bit of lemon or lime or you can add a small amount of Celtic sea salt to increase alkalinity and mineral content.
FORGET ABOUT ALL THE MISLEADING INFORMATION AND REPORTS MADE BY SPORTS OR VITAMIN DRINK COMPANIES TO HELP SELL THEIR HARMFUL PRODUCTS.

POST A COMMENT
*
CAPTCHA image for SPAM prevention
If you can't read the word, click here.
*
*
Advertisement
Advertisement
Australian Drug Foundation, Good Sports Program Keysborough Golf Club. Perfectly positioned within Melbourne's famous sandbelt courses, Keysborough is a demanding and challenging layout set to test professional and club golfers alike. play by the Rules. Making sport inclusive, safe and fair www.Swisse.com.au Army Awards, Challenge yourself News Digital Media Yes Optus